When something goes wrong with your roof, it’s tempting to call the first repair professional you can find. But knowing whether to call a roofer or a handyman can make all the difference — not only in cost, but also in the quality and longevity of the repair.
If you’ve found a leak, noticed a few missing shingles, or have concerns after a storm, you might be asking: Do I need a roofer, or can a handyman handle it? Let’s break down the differences and help you make the right call.
What Does a Roofer Do?
A roofer is a licensed or certified tradesperson who specializes in roof installations, repairs, replacements, and inspections. Roofers are trained to work on various roofing systems — from asphalt shingles and metal roofs to flat commercial roofs — and understand the complex layers that go into protecting a home or building from the elements.
Professional roofers are often equipped to:
-
Diagnose and repair roof leaks
-
Replace missing or damaged shingles
-
Re-seal flashing around chimneys, vents, or skylights
-
Inspect for storm, hail, or wind damage
-
Install new roofing systems
They also typically have access to high-quality roofing materials, insurance coverage, and safety training that allows them to work at height with the right tools and techniques.
What Does a Handyman Do?
A handyman (or handywoman) is a generalist — someone skilled in basic home repairs and maintenance tasks. Handymen can be a great option for small, non-specialized tasks like:
-
Replacing a broken tile
-
Fixing a sticking door
-
Patching minor drywall damage
-
Repairing a small gutter issue
However, most handymen are not trained or licensed to perform complex roof repairs, nor are they typically insured for working on rooftops. And in some areas, performing roof work without the proper licensing can violate building codes or impact insurance coverage.
When Should You Call a Roofer?
If the issue involves the structural integrity of your roof, water penetration, storm damage, or anything that affects your home’s weather protection, it’s time to call a roofer. Examples include:
-
Water stains on your ceiling or walls
-
Shingles curling, cracking, or blowing off
-
Visible damage after a hail or windstorm
-
Leaking around chimneys or roof vents
-
Sagging or warped rooflines
-
Roofs older than 15 years with signs of wear
Roof problems can worsen quickly if not addressed correctly. A licensed roofer can spot deeper issues beneath the surface that a general handyman may miss — and recommend repairs that last.
When a Handyman Might Be Enough
There are a few instances where a handyman may be a reasonable option:
-
Reattaching a loose piece of gutter (at ground level)
-
Sealing a small roof leak in a shed or outbuilding
-
Installing or cleaning minor exterior trim or fascia boards
But even in these cases, if you’re unsure of the underlying cause or if there’s any risk of water intrusion, it’s better to get a roofer’s opinion first. Most roofing companies offer free inspections and will be able to tell you whether it’s a simple fix or something more serious.
Why It Matters Who You Hire
Hiring the wrong type of contractor can lead to:
-
Incomplete repairs that don’t address the root cause
-
Voided warranties, especially on newer roofs
-
Insurance complications if an unlicensed person performs major work
-
Higher costs later to redo improper repairs
-
Fines from your local city government for not having or pulling permits
In short, if the problem involves your roof — even if it seems small — it’s best to get a roofer involved. What looks like a minor issue could be a sign of larger damage beneath the surface.
What to Look for in a Professional Roofer
If you do need a roofer, here are a few tips to ensure you hire the right one:
-
Choose someone licensed and insured
-
Look for experience with your roofing type
-
Ask for photos of past work or client references
-
Ensure they’ll provide a detailed estimate in writing
-
Read online reviews and check for a local reputation
A good roofer won’t pressure you into a full replacement if it’s not necessary. They’ll provide a clear explanation, honest recommendations, and options based on your budget and timeline.
The Bottom Line
When it comes to roof problems, it’s always better to call a roofer than risk a temporary fix that leads to bigger trouble. While handymen play an important role in home maintenance, roof work is too important — and too complex — to leave to anyone but a trained professional.
If you’re unsure whether your issue requires a roofer, most companies will assess the situation at no cost and help you make an informed decision. Peace of mind and protection for your home starts with the right professional on the job.